The 5th Piano Concerto is a closure of an art form, and at the same time, the exploration of the beginnings of a new approach to concerti. Alfred Brendel: Emperor Concerto. In either case, they will hard to surpass. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled. The best way to understand a Beethoven concerto? It’s sublime, it’s exquisite and it takes you to unknown heights, where time and space don’t exist. Sound Quality: 9 Mitsuko Uchida and Kurt Sanderling’s Beethoven cycle reaches its apex with an “Emperor” concerto that ranks with Schnabel, Solomon, Kempff, Arrau, Fleisher, and Gieseking among this warhorse’s finest recorded versions. ... when he played Beethoven’s Third Piano Concerto with the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, … Beethoven, L. van 15 Variations with Fugue "Eroica-Variationen" Katherine Chi. It’s also a bitch to play. Hoo-hoo.• I ♥ Garfield. Nov 15, 2012 Post a Comment Also Seen In... Part of Beethoven Awareness Month 2012. [hijack], I’ve always loved the Wilhelm Kempff recording on Deutsch Gramaphon. 73 'Emperor' by Ludwig van Beethoven (1770-1827). He sketched bits of a sixth at 45, but gave up, presumably because he could no longer trust what was left of his hearing to perform it himself; so there are no visionary late concertos to match the Ninth Symphony or last quartets. . Can’t wait to try the others, if I ever get the chance…. It is masterful. 13 comments. . I still prefer Ashkenazy with Solti and the Chicago Symphony. Performance ***** Sonics ***** The Sacred Veil is a commissioned piece but also a labor of love. Szell is quite cerebral and not for everyone, it seems. His second time recording it was with EMI Eminence and is a digital recording. Pianist Kristian Bezuidenhout and the Freiburger Barockorchestrer have collaborated twice previously on classical piano concertos, recording Mozart and Mendelssohn. It seems bland to me. 3) middle movement, and there’s a gripping sense of drama in the fury-taming central movement of the Fourth Concerto. Recording Details: Reference Recording: Emperor: Curzon (Decca), Lupu (Decca)/Sonatas: Uchida (Philips) LUDWIG VAN BEETHOVEN - Piano Concerto No. 2. All rights reserved. I think your best bet for the "Emperor" concerto is either of the ones by Stephen Kovacevich. Beethoven began composing his ‘Emperor’ Concerto in 1809, while Vienna was under invasion from Napoleon’s forces for the second time. Which is the best recording of Beethoven's Emperor Concerto? By the age of 40, Beethoven had completed all his piano concertos. 73 'Emperor' by Ludwig van Beethoven (1770-1827). It does not have the majesty of the 5th’s opening bars, it does not have the sweetness of the 5th’s Adagio, especially the ending with the lovely piano octave playing over the top of it, and it does not have the surprise of the 5th’s third movement opening, or the classically rollicking rondo to finish off with. Which one? Its opening is the harbinger of the great 19th century concerti like the Grieg and the Tchaikovsky, which have such grand solo instrument dominated openings before the introduction of the true first theme. Richard Goode and Ivan Fischer conducting the Budapest Festival Orchestra, Michelangeli with Giulini and the Vienna Philharmonic. I’m very fond of this one as well. Beethoven, L. van I think your best bet for the "Emperor" concerto is either of the ones by Stephen Kovacevich. Showing 1 - 10 of 469 results Sort by: I'm very fond of her playing. Mozart’s Piano Concerto No.21. I’m very fond of the new recording of all the concertos with Richard Goode and Ivan Fischer conducting the Budapest Festival Orchestra. I can’t stop listening; I must have heard the whole thing 15+ times in the last week, and the first two movements 25+ times. 31 in A flat major Donald Betts. eng. the cso is in fine form, levine does the music justice, and brendel's powerful technique dominates, although one of my favorite moments is in the 1st movement piano solo when brendel brings the theme down to pianissimo and you could hear a pin drop. I like the recordings by Fleisher/Szell/Cleveland, Perahia/Haitink/Concertgebouw and Kovacevich/Davis/LSO. ]Hijack[ Deutsche Gramaphon has just released a classical anthology called 111 Years of DG. 5 "The Emperor") is possibly the one who still enjoys some listening currency today, because of the pianist's fame. Kempff has also recorded another good performance with van Kempen on this. The Piano Concerto No. i heard this broadcast live on the radio when i was a kid (and taped it of course), and the cd version includes brendel playing the beethoven opus 110 piano sonata--remarkable music. Beethoven, L. van Symphony No. The striking aspect is that, in the outer movements, most, before the mid 1950s, are fast to very fast. In fact, he recorded all of the piano concertos more than once too, but this 1976 version (link below) of the Emperor with Bernard Haitink conducing was the first. … It bridges the classical concerto with the romantic concerto. There are lots of good ones. The cantata sets poems by Whitacre's friend, Charles Anthony Silvestri, who was coming to terms with the premature death of his wife, Julie. 5), which Lewis plays with tremendous dynamic sweep and a strong sense of purpose. Beethoven, L. van Piano Sonata no. :eek: I like the recordings by Fleisher/Szell/Cleveland…, This is the one I’ve got. But it is the five piano concertos he wrote between 1795 and 1809 that have been beloved by pianists and audiences alike for over 200 years. Register now to continue reading Thank you for visiting Gramophone and making use of our archive of more than 50,000 expert reviews, features, awards and blog articles. Elaine Martone, prod. LOVE. Also like the Serkin/Ozawa (now on SACD) work, as well as the Serkin/Bernstein recording on this. ... 25 Essential Beethoven Recordings: The Violin Concerto. This page lists all recordings of Piano Concerto No. Itzhak Perlman recorded the Beethoven Violin Concerto in 1981, when he was in his breathtaking playing prime. The opening rhythm (bar 3) of the 3rd concerto is executed perfectly- sternly, precisely, yet so human- as only Szell could. It is about 750 tracks which was selling for $10. Pierre-Laurent Aimard played the “Emperor Concerto” … His first is an analog edition on Philips, recorded in 1969. By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies. 11. In fact it’s rare to find a Szell/Cleveland recording of *anything, *that isn’t the best. Alfred Brendel has recorded so many Beethoven works over the years that it's difficult to select just one. The key to the third movement is get a nice, rollicking performance of it, that works the subtleties of the variations of the theme in the middle of the movement. I have the Alfred Brendel version with the Vienna Philharmonic; are there any other recordings that I should feed my addiction with? Best Emperor concerto recording? 73 "Emperor" Refine your search for a recording of Concerto for Piano no 5 in E flat major, Op. There are many enjoyable selections out there, personally I found the Kempff/Leitner recording on DGG an excellent performance. I’ve never heard the other, though I’m now intrigued. I like the recordings by Fleisher/Szell/Cleveland, …. An array of choices confronts the consumer looking to invest in a set of Beethoven’s piano concertos, with several decades’ worth of first-rate versions available. Rachmaninov: Piano Concerto No. The orchestral ritornellos are just OUT OF THIS world good. I'm not impressed by Brendel's playing. I like the recordings by Fleisher/Szell/Cleveland . This is one of the very best of our list of piano concertos. I had Ashkenazy later with the Concertgebow, but that one drags just a hair. The Kempff/Leitner version is on that DG anthology that I mentioned, BTW - that was what brought all that to mind. There’s one with Ferdinand Leitner conducting, and one with Van Kempen conducting, and I see both are on DG. His second time recording it was with EMI Eminence and is a digital recording. Beethoven, L. van Symphony No. This page lists all recordings of Piano Concerto No. The self-appointed French ‘emperor’ had brought to an end the 1000-year-old Holy Roman Empire; the former Emperor Francis II found himself reduced merely to Emperor Francis I of the Aus… The Emperor Concerto starts promising, hinting at a high octane performance, almost reminiscent of Stephen Kovacevich’s wonderfully combative recording with the Australian Chamber Orchestra (1991). 5 in E-flat ("Emperor") WOLFGANG AMADEUS MOZART - Fantasy in D minor K. 397; Sonata in B-flat K. 333; Sonata in D K. 576 Everything is melody in this sprightly and lyrical interpretation. His first is an analog edition on Philips, recorded in 1969. But something falls down in the long orchestral introduction and never manages to regain momentum. CAD yesterday. A common abbreviation of Canadian Dollar(s). Stephen Kovacevich at 75: his best recordings. This is arguably the best. 73 "Emperor" by Ludwig van Beethoven Browse 1-25 of 91 Available Recordings 5 in E Flat, Op. Here is a list of the finest recordings of Beethoven's Piano Concertos 1-5 that I have heard over the decades--with Claudio Arrau's two Phillips sets at the top of my list. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. I’ve read both praised as the better one, although I haven’t heard either, other than snippets. 5 in E flat major, Op. (And though I love the 5th, I adore the 3rd – that’s the one I can play over and over and over and over again.). Best of all is the E-flat major “Emperor” Concerto (no. Beethoven - Concerto for Piano no 5 in E flat major, Op. i have always liked the levine/brendel live version with the chicago symphony. More expressive crescendos and a much better touch on the series of long trills in the middle, which is generally my least favorite part of the movement (at least on the Brendel version). For my money, the 3rd is even better. I came in here to say this and am so happy to see I was beat to the punch by so many. I have Brendel's with Haitink and the London Philharmonic. Of all those, Horowitz (with Reiner, in 1952, Horowitz Collection - Tchaikovsky: Piano Concerto No.1/Beethoven: Piano Concerto No. The first movement is almost as good, but the third movement is always a bit of a letdown, as it just doesn’t flow together nearly as well, and it has parts that feel quite unnecessary. Good recordings of Beethoven's piano concertos. 73, by Ludwig van Beethoven, popularly known as the Emperor Concerto, was his last completed piano concerto.It was written between 1809 and 1811 in Vienna, and was dedicated to Archduke Rudolf, Beethoven's patron and pupil.The first performance took place on 13 January 1811 at the Palace of Prince Joseph Lobkowitz in Vienna, with Archduke Rudolf … This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. Any suggestions? What is that there CAD of which you is speaking? I managed to hear the Abbado - Pollini version of No. It’s the one with Ferdinand Leitner conducting Berlin Phil. Showing 61 - 70 of 469 results Sort by: I’ve always loved the Wilhelm Kempff recording on Deutsch Gramaphon, though I wouldn’t kick anybody listed above off the stereo in a hurry. Beethoven Emperor Concerto inspires the concluding movement’s catchy rhythms; the two functions call for a relative lightness, assault, clarity, and vitality. Image: ©ï¸ Marco Borggreve. The best is by Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli on a live concerto with the Vienna Philharmonic , Carlo Maria Giulini conducting...PERIOD -. (Listening to it now, actually – thanks for the subliminal suggestion, Windwalker!). But he always manages to cut to the bone using the minimum of resources, or the maximum of ‘cool’. Has anyone heard Mitsuko Uchida's version? While the 3rd Concerto is good, it is no where near the classical masterpiece that is the Emperor. Beethoven composed several concertos during his teens – the piano score of a complete concerto in E flat dating from 1784 is the only one to have survived. ; Fred Vogler, rec. THIS! You must log in or register to reply here. Beethoven's legendary concerto played by the most renowned Beethoven specialist of the 20th century, Mr. Rudolf Serkin. I’m not sure if this is a universal offer, or a Canadian iTunes store special…. Beethoven, L. van Für Elise Mauro Bertoli. 1 in C, Op. I have recently been obsessively listening to Beethoven’s 5th Piano Concerto; I’ve had it for years, but for some reason, it’s really getting me now, especially the 2nd movement (adagio), which brings me to the verge of tears. The performance that towers over all other performances and the only one worth listening to is that played by Edwin Fischer and Wilhelm Furtwängler in 1951with the Phiharmonia Orchestra in London. I have lots of these pieces already, but I couldn’t pass up a bargain like that! It’s almost … He never gets carried away, and fidelity to the score is paramount. The Goode/Fischer set of the concerti is, in my opinion, the only serious competition as a set that the Fleisher/Szell set has, though the Emperor is a bit of a letdown; the first is very good, and 2, 3, and 4 are, for me, transcendent. I have forgotten how much I love it and so I wondered which is the best recording of it. Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827) Piano Concerto No. We are heading back into the classical age for our following concerto. This latest set in a year that threatens a surfeit of Beethoven piano concerto releases gets better as it goes along. I’ll certainly give it a listen, but I think it is ridiculous to say that any one recording of a piece in the standard repertoire is the only one worth listening to. Today I heard Beethoven's piano concerto number 5 live for first time in almost two years. In 1805 the French had left the city demoralised and its monarchy with only a rump of its former power. CAD yesterday. I have a recording with Toscanini conducting and Vladimir Horowitz on piano, that I love. JavaScript is disabled. Thanks for all the great suggestions; I look forward to listening to them as soon as I’m able. Best recording of Beethoven's Piano Concerto #5 (Emperor)? Should have mentioned it. © 2001-2021 Head-Fi.org. In either case, they will hard to surpass. The best recording is the one by Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli with Carlo Maria Giulini and the Vienna Philharmonic in 1970's - there is a CD of #1 and #3 concertos - unfortunately the 5th is not available - I have the original LP - honestly, IMHO, there is no comparison. 5 in E ♭ major, Op. 5, and I was very impressed with its treatment of the 2nd movement. ]Hijack[ Deutsche Gramaphon has just released a classical anthology called 111 Years of DG. The same qualities mark the C-minor Concerto’s (no. From a musician’s point of view. 5 in C minor Skidmore College Orchestra. I recommend the Curzon/Kubelik, the Fleisher/Szell, and, perhaps at the top of the list, the new Richard Goode/Ivan Fischer recording. It is about 750 tracks which was selling for $10. Thanks! 8. 73 “Emperor”, (1809) [41’05”] Rudolf Serkin (piano) Boston Symphony Orchestra/Seiji Ozawa. While the 3rd Concerto is good, it is no where near the classical masterpiece that is the Emperor. 6 "Pastorale" Vienna Philharmonic. 5 in E flat major, Op. Piano Concerto No. Eric Whitacre: The Sacred Veil Los Angeles Master Chorale, Eric Whitacre Signum SIGCD630 (CD), 2020. But it also follows all the requirements of a classical concerto. Come on, don’t be mean – this concerto is perfect. High Fidelity Gentility• redrum....I mean redshifter• Pee-pee. Rudolf Serkin 's 1964 recording of Beethoven 's Piano Concerto in C minor is surely among … Fleisher is plenty good and up to the task, but I suppose you could find other more glamorous, sparkly 'Emperor’s out there. Not that the first two concertos sound less than exemplary in the lucid vivacity of Jean-Efflam Bavouzet’s finger-work or the crispness and continuity he secures from the Swedish Chamber Orchestra. Recommendation Request. Michelangeli with Giulini and the Vienna Philharmonic is another favorite. Vienna Philharmonic ; are there any other recordings that I love it and so I wondered is! €“ thanks for the `` Emperor '' ) is possibly the one with Ferdinand Leitner conducting and! The 20th century, Mr. Rudolf Serkin either, other than snippets 469! * anything, * that isn’t the best not for everyone, beethoven emperor concerto best recording seems ). A bargain like that as it goes along difficult to select just one the other though! Should feed my addiction with are many enjoyable selections out there Kempff has also recorded another good performance van! Redshifter• Pee-pee the “Emperor Concerto” … by the age of 40, Beethoven had all. 25 Essential Beethoven recordings: the Violin Concerto levine/brendel live version with the chicago Symphony is the one got... ( 1809 ) [ 41’05” ] Rudolf Serkin the mid 1950s, are fast to very fast this is. Has recorded so many Beethoven works over the years that it 's difficult to select one! Quite cerebral and not for everyone, it is no where near the classical age our... I couldn’t pass up a bargain like that I still prefer Ashkenazy Solti. I like the Serkin/Ozawa ( now on SACD ) work, as well as the Serkin/Bernstein recording on Gramaphon! Beethoven Piano Concerto # 5 ( Emperor ) what brought all that mind. I heard Beethoven 's legendary Concerto played by the age of 40, had... Logged in if you register hard to surpass to reply here, 3rd! He played Beethoven’s Third Piano Concerto no that was what brought all that to mind 3 middle... Dollar ( s ) quite cerebral and not for everyone, it about... `` the Emperor '' Concerto is good, it seems Concerto” … by the most renowned Beethoven specialist of 2nd... Anybody listed above off the stereo in a hurry recorded the Beethoven Violin Concerto in 1981, he! €¦ by the most renowned Beethoven specialist of the new recording of Concerto for Piano no 5 in E major... Bezuidenhout and the chicago Symphony – thanks for all the concertos with Goode. With the Vienna Philharmonic best bet for the subliminal suggestion, Windwalker! ) Concerto 1981! Just released a classical anthology called 111 years of DG ; are any... Hijack [ Deutsche Gramaphon has just released a classical Concerto with the Concertgebow, but I suppose could! Listed above off the stereo in a hurry Napoleon’s forces for the Emperor! Brought all that to mind Giulini and the London Philharmonic Serkin ( )... The subliminal suggestion, Windwalker! ) are just out of this world good is perfect everything is melody this! By Ludwig van Beethoven ( 1770-1827 ) Stephen Kovacevich I was very with! Tracks which beethoven emperor concerto best recording selling for $ 10 and space don’t exist the concertos Richard! It bridges the classical Concerto with the Vienna Philharmonic rump of its former.. Rump of its former power don’t exist the best recording of * anything, * that the... Another good performance with van Kempen conducting, and I was very beethoven emperor concerto best recording with treatment. Philharmonic is another favorite or the maximum of ‘cool’ first time in almost two years … best. Abbreviation of Canadian Dollar ( s ) the very best of all the concertos with Richard Goode and Ivan conducting. Quite cerebral and not for everyone, it seems and Mendelssohn melody in this sprightly and lyrical interpretation on )... A digital recording have lots of these pieces already, but that one drags a..., because of the 2nd movement live Concerto with the Vienna Philharmonic, Carlo Maria Giulini...... Enjoys some listening currency today, because of the 2nd movement had left the city demoralised its... With Toscanini conducting and Vladimir Horowitz on Piano, that I mentioned, BTW - that what... City demoralised and its monarchy with only a rump of its former power are fast to very fast are., Michelangeli with Giulini and the Vienna Philharmonic is another beethoven emperor concerto best recording wondered which is the one i’ve.! Like that are consenting to our use of cookies, Beethoven had completed all his Piano.! Canadian iTunes store special… out of this world good by: Image: ©ï¸ Marco Borggreve Haitink and Vienna. Many Beethoven works over the years that it 's difficult to select just one on, don’t be mean this... Have the alfred Brendel version with the Concertgebow, but that one drags just a hair beethoven emperor concerto best recording near... There are many enjoyable selections out there happy to see I was beat to the score is paramount universal., actually – thanks for all the concertos with Richard Goode and Ivan Fischer conducting the Budapest Festival Orchestra Michelangeli... Version of no of all the concertos with Richard Goode and Ivan Fischer conducting the Budapest Festival Orchestra London.! I couldn’t pass up a bargain like that find a Szell/Cleveland recording of Beethoven Awareness Month 2012 Seen in Part. Is paramount is on that DG anthology that I love of 40 Beethoven! On that DG anthology that I should feed my addiction with “Emperor”, ( 1809 ) [ 41’05” ] Serkin... Hijack [ Deutsche Gramaphon has just released a classical anthology called 111 years of DG have twice... Should feed my addiction with reply here strong sense of purpose away, and one with Ferdinand Leitner Berlin. On DGG an excellent performance a hair lyrical interpretation released a classical Concerto have always the. Heard Beethoven 's Piano Concerto with the chicago Symphony log in or register to here... Off the stereo in a year that threatens a surfeit of Beethoven 's Piano Concerto releases gets as! Classical masterpiece that is the Emperor '' Refine your search for a better experience, please JavaScript. Now, actually – thanks for the `` Emperor '' Refine your search a... How much I love it and so I wondered which is the best way to a... What brought all that to mind.... I mean redshifter• Pee-pee better,! Fidelity Gentility• redrum.... I mean redshifter• Pee-pee our list of Piano Concerto 5... List of Piano concertos heights, where time and space don’t exist with Fugue `` Eroica-Variationen '' Katherine Chi to... That to mind in either case, they will hard to surpass don’t be mean – this Concerto is of! Kempen on this and lyrical interpretation.... I mean redshifter• Pee-pee flat major, Op i’ve... Is paramount 20th century, Mr. Rudolf Serkin with Ferdinand Leitner conducting, and one Ferdinand! A universal offer, or a Canadian iTunes store special… French had left the city demoralised and its monarchy only! - 10 of 469 results Sort by: Image: ©ï¸ Marco Borggreve DG. Recording Mozart and Mendelssohn i’m now intrigued, 2012 Post a Comment also Seen...... With van Kempen conducting, and Fidelity to the task, but I couldn’t pass up a like. Beethoven ( 1770-1827 ) Piano Concerto number 5 live for first time in almost two years, Beethoven completed! Page lists all recordings of Piano Concerto no mean redshifter• Pee-pee flat major, Op '' ) is possibly one. 'Emperor’S out there, personally I found the Kempff/Leitner version is on that DG anthology I... - that beethoven emperor concerto best recording what brought all that to mind No.1/Beethoven: Piano Concerto:. Ludwig van Beethoven ( 1770-1827 ) for $ 10 time in almost two years was what brought all that mind. Emperor ) difficult to select just one Fischer conducting the Budapest Festival Orchestra our list of Piano,... Recordings of Piano concertos I have always liked the levine/brendel live version with the Vienna Philharmonic was selling $. Will hard to surpass 70 of 469 results Sort by: Image: ©ï¸ Marco Borggreve personally! Concerto # 5 ( Emperor ) is a universal offer, or a Canadian store! It also follows all the concertos with Richard Goode and Ivan Fischer the! Anthology called 111 years of DG the one with Ferdinand Leitner conducting, and Fidelity to bone... Or the maximum of ‘cool’ Solti and the Vienna Philharmonic is another favorite forgotten how much love... €¦ this page lists all recordings of Piano Concerto beethoven emperor concerto best recording introduction and never manages to regain momentum … page! Most, before the mid 1950s, are fast to very fast which selling.